Avoid common mistakes with crop insurance

Law of the Land

Brion Doyle | October 17, 2013

Brion Doyle pngWith federal crop insurance now available to Michigan tart cherry growers and with other farmers considering or reconsidering crop insurance following adverse weather conditions in recent years, it is important to understand the different protections that crop insurance can provide and how to maximize those protections in the event of a loss. 

Federal crop insurance has its origins in the Dust Bowl era of the 1930s, when Congress created the taxpayer-subsidized insurance program to protect farmers against crop losses. Today, the USDA's Risk Management Agency (RMA) manages federal crop insurance and contracts with the 19 Approved Insurance Providers (AIPs), the private insurance companies that provide policies to farmers.

The two most recognized types of crop insurance policies available to farmers are crop-hail policies and Multiple Peril Crop Insurance (MPCI). Crop-hail policies are not part of the federal crop insurance program and are provided directly to farmers by private insurers. Crop-hail policies can be purchased at any time during the growing season. MPCI, in contrast, is the crop insurance plan developed and rated by the USDA. MPCI policies offer a yield guarantee based on the Actual Production History (APH) of the individual producer and provide protection from a variety of natural causes, including drought, excessive moisture, freeze, and disease. 

Farmers considering federal crop insurance coverage can also choose among new coverage options that offer a combination of revenue and yield protection, including Crop Revenue Coverage (CRC), Revenue Assurance (RA), Income Protection (IP), at varying levels of coverage for the insured crop. It is also important that farmers do not overlook Catastrophic (CAT) coverage, which, while only offering partial protection against significant crop failure, is essentially free.

Once the appropriate coverage is selected, there are several steps that an insured can take to reduce potential disputes and maximize recovery in the event of a loss. First, farmers must be mindful of several important deadlines, including:

• the deadline for applying for coverage
• the final planting date
• the acreage reporting date, and
• the deadline for filing notice of crop damage. 

In addition, the RMA reports several common mistakes that can lead to a reduction or elimination of coverage, including underreporting or overreporting planted acreage, failing to report all farm serial numbers planted to the insured crop, failing to report the production of all farm serial numbers, failing to elect "new producer" status, harvesting the crop in a manner other than insured (i.e., harvesting corn as silage when it is insured as grain), and destroying insured crop without the insurance company's approval. 

Finally, perhaps the most important step a farmer can take is to organize and keep complete records relating to all insured crops. Farmers have a duty under their federal crop insurance policy to keep records related to the planting, replanting, inputs, harvesting, production, and sale of the insured crop. Well-organized records can be the key to preventing or winning a crop insurance dispute. 

Record droughts in recent years, damaging frosts, and once-in-a-lifetime flooding have all highlighted the need for crop insurance as a risk management tool. At the same time, as crop insurance indemnities set new records in 2011 and 2012, crop insurance disputes also are likely to rise. For this reason, in addition to selecting the most appropriate policy, farmers must be proactive in following the policy requirements and retaining and organizing their records in order to minimize and prevent the delay or denial of coverage. And because the decision regarding what type of crop insurance policy and what level of coverage to purchase can be quite complex, it is important for farmers to consult with their insurance agent to carefully consider coverage needs.

This advisory has been prepared by Varnum LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Leave a comment
Name *
Email *



Blogs & Columns


 Columns Grey

March quarterly stock report

Market Outlook

Dr. Jim Hilker | February 28, 2015

Jim Hilker png The March 1 Quarterly Stocks report showed 1,224 million bushels on hand three-fourths of the way through the 2014-'15 wheat marketing year. That was 19 million fewer bushels than the trade expected on average, and 67 million more bushels than last year. Michigan had 20.75 million bushels on hand, down 7.7 million from last year. Most of it was in off farm storage.

Slightly above normal for March

Weather Outlook

Jeff Andresen | February 15, 2015

Jeff Andresen pngFor March, mean temperatures ranged from near or even slightly above normal across western sections of Upper Michigan to 2 degrees F-4 degrees below normal across central and eastern sections of the state. Drier-than-normal conditions continued, with monthly precipitation totals ranging from half-an-inch or less many areas of the Lower Peninsula to just under 1.5 inches across sections of Upper Michigan. These totals range from less than 25 percent of normal across southern Michigan to about 75 percent or normal in the Upper Peninsula.

In honor of Al Gore, my friends at the EPA, and Prius drivers everywhere, this edition is devoted to EARTH DAY.

Opinion blog

Damian Mason | April 20, 2015

Damian Mason BlogMost farmers and ranchers have the bulk of their net worth - and life’s work - invested in land. Between Mother Nature, the banker, and the desire to pass on the family farm, we’re fully invested in Earth. Out here, every day is Earth Day!

What impacts interest rates and how are they determined?

Dollars and Sense

GreenStone FCS | April 1, 2015

Travis Jones - GreenStone FSC

Due to the improving labor market, economists are anticipating the FOMC to start slowly increasing the Fed Funds target rate sometime between June and December of this year.


I wanna be offended when I grow up

Opinion blog

Damian Mason | March 25, 2015

Damian Mason BlogBeing offended isn't a job, you say?  Sure it is, and those who devote their work week to the profession are growing by leaps and bounds.